Textile marking techniques: the comparison!

PrintMyTransfer > How does it work? > Tips blog > Textile marking techniques: the comparison!
[19/10/2017]

Would you like to create customized textiles? Do you feel lost among the existing marking techniques? Here is a comparison of the most well-known marking techniques to help you make your choice!


Textile marking techniques: the comparison!

There are indeed several ways to print a logo, an illustration or a photo on a textile.

Today, we will try to shed some light on the different marking techniques that exist so that you can make the best choice for your textile printing.

Here is a comparison of the most well-known marking techniques:

Textile flocking

Direct screen printing

Screen-printed transfer

Transfer sublimation

Textile embroidery

Direct digital printing

Digital transfer

DTF transfer

Comparison table

Textile flocking

What is textile flocking?

Textile flocking is one of the best-known printing systems among the general public. Widely used in the world of sport, it is notably used for marking T-shirts.
This technique involves printing a design on a flex roll, then cutting it using a cutting plotter. The flex is then bonded to the textile using a heat press.

Advantages of textile flocking

  • Multi-support printing (textiles)

  • The lifespan of the product in good condition is acceptable

  • The order can be individually personalised

Disadvantages of textile flocking

  • The design must be simple

  • The design must use few colours and have no special colours

  • This marking technique does not handle gradients
  • Requires cutting (plotter purchase, preparation time)

Use cases for textile flocking

Flocking is often used for simple, low-colour visuals in small and medium runs. Having a relatively acceptable lifespan, this technique lends itself easily to the sporting world.

Direct screen printing

What is direct screen printing?

Direct screen printing is a craft process that remains one of the oldest textile printing techniques. This process is "a classic" in the world of textile printing.
On the technical side, it involves using screen printing screens that work like stencils to pass ink onto the textile to be marked. The ink spreads onto the textile through a stretched mesh. This allows colour-by-colour printing on garments.

Advantages of direct screen printing

- It is a durable product over time

- Thanks to its ink deposit, the final appearance is of high quality. The colours retain their brightness from day one

- Suitable for small and medium runs

Disadvantages of direct screen printing

- The minimum quantity varies depending on the complexity of the design and the number of colours

- The rendering of complex designs containing details is often disappointing

Use cases for direct screen printing

Direct screen printing is more suitable for producing on simple textiles with uncomplicated designs and few colours.

Screen-printed transfer

What is screen-printed transfer?

Screen-printed transfer is a high-quality textile printing solution.
This technique involves depositing inks onto transfer paper and then, in a second step, transferring it onto a textile support using a heat press.

Advantages of screen-printed transfer

- A high-quality result that lasts a long time! Repeated washing does not affect the quality of the product

- Excellent colour management: from single-colour to four-colour printing via multi-colour

- Impeccable application on all supports: T-shirts, caps, luggage, coats whether light or dark

Disadvantages of screen-printed transfer

- The final result depends greatly on the quality of the initial file provided

- Gradients are only possible on a flat colour background with white support. Fade gradients are only possible on white textile

Use cases for screen-printed transfer

Screen-printed transfer can be used for small and large runs, and for all types of textile. It is particularly suited for the visual communication of organisations.

Transfer sublimation

What is transfer sublimation?

Sublimation is a recent marking technique that uses inks. It involves printing a visual using sublimation inks on special paper with a high-quality printer. The paper is then pressed onto the garment using a heat press and removed. As a result, the ink is directly injected into the fabric.

Advantages of transfer sublimation

- Since the ink is directly injected into the fabric, the design is indelible! It is therefore resistant to the elements and accidents

- Excellent colour and contrast management

- High quality rendering on polyester, lycra, etc.

Disadvantages of transfer sublimation

- The choice of textile is limited both in colour and material

- The costs of this type of service are high

Use cases for transfer sublimation

Sublimation is mainly used for quality rendering on white textiles. This technique is ideal for sportswear and technical garments.

Textile embroidery

What is textile embroidery?

Textile embroidery is the oldest marking technique mentioned in this article. It involves reproducing a visual using threads and needles.

Advantages of textile embroidery

- The quality of the result is very good

- Durable printing on waterproofed textiles

- The design has very good washing resistance and can therefore last over time

- The design has a relief effect

Disadvantages of textile embroidery

- Production costs are higher than for other techniques
- Not all visuals can be reproduced. For example, gradients are not possible
- The risk of damaging certain fabrics must be taken into account
- No exact match with Pantone colours

Use cases for textile embroidery

Embroidery marking is favoured by high-end brands.

Direct digital printing

What is digital printing?

Having arrived in the world of textile printing in recent years, digital printing is carried out directly on textile from the digital file.

Advantages of digital printing

- This allows printing of large formats (37*47cm)
- The choice of colours is unlimited!
- Possibility of printing on light and dark textiles

Disadvantages of digital printing

- It is only possible to mark the front and back

- Printing only on cotton or polyester/cotton

- Restricted to fabrics made up of around 70% cotton, to ensure a good hold

Use cases for digital printing

Direct digital printing is recommended if your designs or photos are composed of a large number of colours or gradients, as well as for small or medium runs.

Digital transfer

What is digital transfer?

Also known as digital transfer or digital flex, digital transfer involves printing a design onto a special thermoadhesive film using a digital printer. The excess material must then be weeded to retain only the design. The transfer is then carried out using a heat press.

Advantages of digital transfer

- Ideal for small runs

- Unlimited number of colours

- Possibility of printing gradients

Disadvantages of digital transfer

- Fragile and has a short lifespan

- Difficulties in printing complex designs

Use cases for digital transfer

Digital transfer is well suited to light-coloured textiles for quick and low-cost personalisation needs.

DTF (Direct-To-Film) transfer

What is DTF transfer?

DTF is a digital technology: the visual is printed in full colour onto a transparent film, then transferred to the fabric with a heat press. It is the fast, versatile solution for small and medium runs.

Advantages of DTF transfer

- Photo-quality full-colour printing, with gradients and fine detail down to 0.3 mm

- No outline or overhang: the visual blends perfectly into the fabric

- Great versatility: applies to most standard textiles, light or dark

- No minimum number of colours: a highly colourful visual costs no more than a single-colour one

- Quick and easy application in seconds with a heat press

Disadvantages of DTF transfer

- For very intensive washing and long service life on large runs, the screen-printed transfer keeps the advantage

- As with any digital printing, the final result depends on the quality of the visual supplied at the outset

Use cases for DTF transfer

DTF is ideal for photographic, colourful or detailed visuals, in small and medium runs, with an excellent flexibility/speed ratio. For a detailed comparison with screen printing (full table, FAQ), see our article Screen printing or DTF: which technique to choose?

Comparison of the different marking techniques: summary table

Techniques

Textile flocking

Direct screen printing

Screen-printed transfer

Sublimation

Textile embroidery

Direct digital printing

Digital transfer

Lifespan

Average

Good

Good

Good

Very good

Good

Low

Quality

Average

High

High

Very high

Very high

Average

Average

Number of colours per design

Limited

Limited

Unlimited

Unlimited

Very limited

Unlimited

Unlimited

Colour choice

Restricted

Very wide

Very wide

Unlimited

Restricted

Unlimited

Unlimited

Gradients possible

No

Yes but not recommended

Yes on white textiles

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Design complexity

Simple design

Simple design preferred

Simple and complex design

Simple and complex design

Simple design

Simple and complex design

Simple design

Format

All formats

All formats

All formats

All formats

Small and medium

All formats

All formats

Cost

Average

Low in large quantities

Average

High

Very high

Average

Average

There you have it: you now have all the cards in hand to choose the textile marking technique that suits you. If you are still hesitating, do not worry, we are here to help you choose the marking process best suited to your needs.